Twitter Facebook Print PDF   |   ... more



US Central Command Seeks to Legitimize Hamas and Hizb'Allah

[Mark Perry, Foreign Policy]

Summary ... In what can only be termed an incredible development, senior intelligence officers at US Central Command (CENTCOM) are recommending that Hizb'Allah and Hamas be designated as political parties instead of terrorist organizations. The stance is at once provocative, controversial and at odds with current US policy.

While it is anathema to broach the subject of engaging militant groups like Hizb'Allah and Hamas in official Washington circles (to say nothing of Israel), that is exactly what a team of senior intelligence officers at US Central Command — CENTCOM — has been doing. In a "Red Team" report issued on May 7 and entitled "Managing Hizb'Allah and Hamas," senior CENTCOM intelligence officers question the current US policy of isolating and marginalizing the two movements. Instead, the Red Team recommends a mix of strategies that would integrate the two organizations into their respective political mainstreams. While a Red Team exercise is deliberately designed to provide senior commanders with briefings and assumptions that challenge accepted strategies, the report is at once provocative, controversial — and at odds with current US policy.

Among its other findings, the five-page report calls for the integration of Hizb'Allah into the Lebanese Armed Forces, and Hamas into the Palestinian [sic] security forces led by Fatah, the party of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas. The Red Team's conclusion, expressed in the final sentence of the executive summary, is perhaps its most controversial finding: "The US role of assistance to an integrated Lebanese defense force that includes Hizb'Allah; and the continued training of Palestinian security forces in a Palestinian entity that includes Hamas in its government, would be more effective than providing assistance to entities — the government of Lebanon and Fatah — that represent only a part of the Lebanese and Palestinian populace respectively" (emphasis in the original). The report goes on to note that while Hizb'Allah and Hamas "embrace staunch anti-Israel rejectionist policies," the two groups are "pragmatic and opportunistic."

The report opens with a quote from former US peace negotiator Aaron David Miller's book, The Much Too Promised Land, which notes that both Hizb'Allah and Hamas "have emerged as serious political players respected on the streets, in Arab capitals, and throughout the region. Destroying them was never really an option. Ignoring them may not be either." The report's writers are quick to acknowledge that the two militant groups "are vastly different," and that treating them together is a mistake. Nevertheless, the CENTCOM team directly repudiates Israel's publicly stated view — that the two movements are incapable of change and must be confronted with force. The report says that "failing to recognize their separate grievances and objectives will result in continued failure in moderating their behavior."

"There is a lot of thinking going on in the military and particularly among intelligence officers in Tampa [the site of CENTCOM headquarters] about these groups," acknowledged a senior CENTCOM officer familiar with the report. However, he denied that senior military leaders are actively lobbying Barack Obama's administration to forge an opening to the two organizations. "That's probably not in the cards just yet," he said.

In the wake of the Gaza flotilla incident, Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Daniel Ayalon said that those on board the Mavi Marmara, the scene of the May 31 showdown between Israeli commandos and largely Turkish activists, had ties to "agents of international terror, international Islam, Hamas, al Qaeda and others." The same senior officer wasn't impressed. "Putting Hizb'Allah, Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood and al Qaeda in the same sentence, as if they are all the same, is just stupid," he said. "I don't know any intelligence officer at CENTCOM who buys that." Another mid-level SOCOM [Special Operations Command] officer echoed these views: "As the US strategy in the war on terrorism evolves, military planners have come to realize that they are all motivated by different factors, and we need to address this if we are going to effectively prosecute a successful campaign in the Middle East."

The most interesting aspects of the report deal with Hizb'Allah. The Red Team downplays the argument that the Lebanese Shi'ite group acts as a proxy for Iran. The report includes a quote from Hizb'Allah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah, stating that if Lebanon and Iran's interests ever conflicted, his organization would favor Lebanese interests. "Hizb'Allah's activities increasingly reflect the movement's needs and aspirations in Lebanon, as opposed to the interests of its Iranian backers," the report concludes. It also criticizes Israel's August 2006 war against Hizb'Allah as counterproductive. "Instead of exploiting Hizb'Allah's independent streak ... Israeli actions in Lebanon may have had the reverse effect of tightening its bonds with Iran," the authors note.

The report goes on to say that, while there are "many ways in which Lebanese Hizb'Allah is not like the IRA," there are "parallels" between the Irish Republican Army's eventual participation in the Northern Ireland peace process and a potentially productive US strategy for dealing with Hizb'Allah. CENTCOM officers cite a meeting between the British ambassador to Lebanon and Hizb'Allah leaders in 2009 as providing an appropriate model to begin the integration of the organization into the LAF. Such talks should "be pursued again with the same vigor that peace talks in Northern Ireland were pursued," the report recommends. "As the US took the lead with peace talks in Northern Ireland, the British could take the lead with unity talks between the LAF and Hizb'Allah in Lebanon."

The brief's authors also have interesting things to say about Hamas, which has ruled in Gaza since its takeover of the impoverished coastal strip in 2007. While the Red Team report does not make explicit policy recommendations, the senior intelligence experts that drafted the statement signal their unease with Israel's anti-Hamas policies, particularly the continuing Israeli siege of Gaza. CENTCOM officers note that Israel's strategy of keeping Gaza under siege also keeps "the area on the verge of a perpetual humanitarian collapse" — a policy that the intelligence report says "may be radicalizing more people, especially the young, increasing the number of potential recruits" for the organization. The report argues that an Israeli decision to lift the siege might pave the way for reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas, which would be "the best hope for mainstreaming Hamas." The Red Team also claims that reconciliation with Fatah, when coupled with Hamas's explicit renunciation of violence, would gain "widespread international support and deprive the Israelis of any legitimate justification to continue settlement building and delay statehood negotiations."

In supporting the creation of a unified Palestinian security service, CENTCOM's Red Team distances itself from the US effort to provide training to the Fatah-controlled security forces in the West Bank, which began during George W. Bush's administration. While that effort, currently headed by Lt. Gen. Keith Dayton, is not mentioned specifically in the report, the Red Team makes it clear that it believes that such initiatives will fail unless the Israelis and Palestinians [sic] negotiate an end to the conflict. While Dayton and the administration are focused on building a "National Security Force" in the West Bank that excludes Hamas, and jails its members, the focus of Palestinians is elsewhere. "But all Palestinians are watching the clashes in East Jerusalem, which continue to feed into the Palestinians perception the Israelis are incapable of negotiating in good faith," according to the report.

CENTCOM's implicit criticism of Dayton is not a surprise: the general's program is controversial among some senior military officers, who question an effort that, in Palestinian perceptions, makes the US a partner in the Israeli occupation. Dayton is also criticized in military circles for making a May 2009 speech before the pro-Israel Washington Institute for Near East Policy (which he described as "the foremost think tank on Middle East issues, not only in Washington, but in the world"). In the speech , he said that the reason a high-ranking general was appointed as security coordinator was because he "would be trusted and respected by the Israelis." The statement was not universally welcomed at the Pentagon, where one officer shook his head. "You would have thought Dayton's primary mission would be to win the respect and trust of the Palestinians," he told me.

According to a senior CENTCOM officer, while the CENTCOM Red Team report has been read by outgoing CENTCOM chief Gen. David Petraeus, it's unknown whether its recommendations have been passed on to the White House. Even so, there's little question the report reflects the thinking among a significant number of senior officers at CENTCOM headquarters — and among senior CENTCOM intelligence officers and analysts serving in the Middle East. And while any "Red Team" report by definition reflects a view that is contrary to accepted policy, a CENTCOM senior officer told me that — so far as he knows — there is, in fact, no parallel "Blue Team" report contradicting the Red Team's conclusion. "Well, that's not exactly right," this senior officer added. "The Blue Team is the Obama administration."

See Also

[ Published: July 26, 2010 ]



Keep current with these articles

Sign up to receive free e-mail alerts.

  

Need to find additional information?

There are 3 comments
Daniel Hill
July 22, 2013 - 03:31 PM MDT

Even though these various groups operate differently and are often in conflict with one another, they all have one thing in common, and that's their desire for the destruction of Israel. They will of course be happy to receive any concessions the west or Israel are naive enough to give them, and you can depend that they will make promises of peace in order to acquire those concessions. If I had to hazard a guess as to the true source of the new attitudes in the CIA, I would place my bets on the Muslim in the White House.

Reply to Daniel Hill
Lee
August 12, 2013 - 01:41 PM MDT

There really are no "new attitudes in the CIA". The CIA's attitude towards Israel have always been the same; the current administration has changed nothing. Actually, although it "technically" operates under the authority of the Executive branch, history has proven that the CIA generally operates on its own authority, as do all other US intelligence agencies.

Norm Singer
July 26, 2010 - 09:13 PM MDT

To: CENTCOM

When all the superfluous wording is pared away, we can see the essence of your message:
"It is difficult to manage so many disparate groups. This can be corrected by having several of these groups join together, resulting in our having to deal with fewer groups."

WRONG! on many counts

First, Hamas and Fatah have been at each other's throats: you want to have these two hostile entities join forces...essentially for your own convenience? What are you smoking?

At the same time, you want to complete the destruction of Lebanon by doing to the Lebanese what Hizb' Allah has been unable to complete on its own? Hizb'Allah will leave no trace of Lebanon or the Lebanese un-damaged. A vast number of Lebanese will be dead within weeks.

Please tell me, for which side in this millenial struggle between freedom and barbarism...for whcih side do think you're working?

Finally, for these comments, by choosing your convenience over the integrity and freedom of your country, you make a cosmic error that could well be Lethal to all of us.

Please read authoritative books written by people (NOT Islamists) who have dedicated their lives to studying the Sociology, Psychology and History of the people who you are wanting to manipulate.
When you've done that reading, then you'll be in a position to see how grievously you have erred in your judgment of the situation.

Tell me, Would you, without any study, attempt to compund an explosive in your kitchen?
While you children slept upstairs?

Leave a Comment



? ? ?

Powered by TalkBack


In Depth Analysis

Between the Settlers and the Unsettlers, the One-State Solution Is on Our Doorstep

The Middle East is falling apart, or at least most of it. As things progress, Israel will soon be the only state able to govern Judea and Samaria, and the only military force capable of securing its borders. How will it happen?

Patrons of Terror: A Brief History

Over the years Europe, the UN, and world leaders such as US Presidents Carter and Clinton, the Pope have become some of the leading supporters of terrorism. But more surprisingly Israeli prime ministers, beginning with the late Yitzhak Rabin, followed by Shimon Peres, Benjamin Netanyahu, Ehud Barak, Ehud, Olmert, and Ariel Sharon have themselves become patrons of terrorism, but making them more culpable due to the position they hold within Israel.

Why Does Israel Play the "Palestine" and "Palestinians" Game?

Why does the Israeli government continue to give credence to the lie that there really is a "Palestinian" people and that "Palestine" was once an actual country? It certainly does not serve the needs of the nation of Israel, except to give weak-kneed politicians a reason for not standing up and doing their job.

Emet Blog

Let Us Finish the Job

It is time to drop our flyers in Gaza. Let us warn them to leave. When the time period on those flyers elapses — then the carpet bombing must begin. Then the infantry must follow. If Israel does not overcome their gentle peace-seeking natures, it will be their children who will pay with their lives. End this nightmare once and for all.

US State Department, French Embassy Partner in Anti-Semitic Book Fair

The U.S. State Department is listed as a "cultural partner" of the 24th Abu Dhabi International Book Fair, held from April 30 to May 5. Among the anti-Semitic publications on display at the fair (in both English and Arabic) — books which paved the way for the Holocaust — are The International Jew, Mein Kampf and The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion.

Ten Websites About the Holocaust

Holocaust Remembrance Day (Yom Hashoah) is a national day of commemoration in Israel, remembering the six million Jews who were brutally murdered in the Holocaust. These ten Web sites focus on the Holocaust. Some of them tell the history of what happened, others give the names of those who died and others provide documents, pictures, and other information.

Views/Commentary

A Letter to US Ambassador to Israel, Dan Shapiro, Regarding Jonathan Pollard

US President Obama continually refuses to release Jonathan Pollard from prison despite the fact that many Israeli and US government leaders, including those from the FBI, CIA, NSA and Department of Justice, have called for his release. Contrary to statements spread by uninformed individuals, Pollard was never indicted for harming the United States, for compromising codes, agents, or war plans, nor was he ever charged with treason. Pollard was indicted on only one charge: one count of passing classified information to an ally, without intent to harm the United States, for which the usual sentence is only two to four years. One fact that stands out significantly is that while the United States continues to refuse to honor the plea agreement it made with Pollard, it demands that Israel release hundreds of terrorists who have been tried and convicted of committing multiple, heinous murders, of whom many of the victims are US citizens.

Examining the Roots of Historical Jewish Music

Music from the Jewish culture allows historians and other researchers to discover Jewish history from a unique point of view. Jewish music provides insight into details not usually found in common historical artifacts. Many organizations, specifically created for the research and study of Jewish music, are providing a wealth of information not previously known in that field of study.

Remembering Irena Sendler

Irena Sendler was a Polish Gentile who rescued more than 2,500 Jewish children from the Warsaw ghetto. The Life in a Jar project celebrates her accomplishments in defeating Hitler's intended murder of these children.

Selected Reading

Israel in Figures 2013 - Central Bureau of Statistics

This booklet covers a broad range of topics related to Israeli demography, society, and economy. Included are facts about the government and its founding, facts about the land itself, as well as population, standard of living information, education and economic stats and many other details about the nation. Very good background information.

Are Settlements Illegal?

The world declares that the Jewish settlements in Judea and Samaria are illegal and must be destroyed and the Jews relocated. They base their claim on either the Geneva Convention, UN General Assembly Resolution 181, UN Security Council Resolution 242, or any number of other documents. The facts, however, prove otherwise. The Jewish settlements in Judea and Samaria are, in fact, quite legal, under the provisions set forth in the previously mentioned documents and others, including the Balfour Declaration and the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine.

Is Jerusalem Sacred for Muslims?

Muslims claim that Jerusalem is sacred for two reasons: First, Muslims were initially commanded to pray toward Jerusalem. But when the Jews refused to convert to Islam, Muhammad changed the prayer direction toward Mecca. Second, Muslims believe that Muhammad ascended to heaven and back from "the Rock" which much later after his death was interpreted to mean what is today the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. Interestingly though, Islamic sources from the first 50 years or so after Muhammad's death make clear that Jerusalem had absolutely no holy status for Muslims.

Why Is Israel's Presence in the Territories Still Called "Occupation"?

When an armed force holds territory beyond its own national borders, the term "occupation" is usually used to describe its holding on the land. However, not all the factual situations that we commonly think of as "occupation" fall within the limited scope of the term "occupation" as defined in international law.

The History and Meaning of "Palestine" and "Palestinians"

Palestine has never existed . . . as an autonomous entity. There is no language known as Palestinian. There is no distinct Palestinian culture. There has never been a land known as Palestine governed by Palestinians. Palestinians are Arabs.